bytes, strings: optimize for ASCII sets
In a large codebase within Google, there are thousands of uses of:
ContainsAny|IndexAny|LastIndexAny|Trim|TrimLeft|TrimRight
An analysis of their usage shows that over 97% of them only use character
sets consisting of only ASCII symbols.
Uses of ContainsAny|IndexAny|LastIndexAny:
6% are 1 character (e.g., "\n" or " ")
58% are 2-4 characters (e.g., "<>" or "\r\n\t ")
24% are 5-9 characters (e.g., "()[]*^$")
10% are 10+ characters (e.g., "+-=&|><!(){}[]^\"~*?:\\/ ")
We optimize for ASCII sets, which are commonly used to search for
"control" characters in some string. We don't optimize for the
single character scenario since IndexRune or IndexByte could be used.
Uses of Trim|TrimLeft|TrimRight:
71% are 1 character (e.g., "\n" or " ")
14% are 2 characters (e.g., "\r\n")
10% are 3-4 characters (e.g., " \t\r\n")
5% are 10+ characters (e.g., "
0123456789abcdefABCDEF")
We optimize for the single character case with a simple closured function
that only checks for that character's value. We optimize for the medium
and larger sets using a 16-byte bit-map representing a set of ASCII characters.
The benchmarks below have the following suffix name "%d:%d" where the first
number is the length of the input and the second number is the length
of the charset.
== bytes package ==
benchmark old ns/op new ns/op delta
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:1-4 5.09 5.23 +2.75%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:2-4 5.81 5.85 +0.69%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:4-4 7.22 7.50 +3.88%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:8-4 11.0 11.1 +0.91%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:16-4 17.5 17.8 +1.71%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:1-4 36.0 34.0 -5.56%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:2-4 46.6 36.5 -21.67%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:4-4 78.0 40.4 -48.21%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:8-4 136 47.4 -65.15%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:16-4 254 61.5 -75.79%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:1-4 542 388 -28.41%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:2-4 705 382 -45.82%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:4-4 1089 386 -64.55%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:8-4 1994 394 -80.24%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:16-4 3843 411 -89.31%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:1-4 8522 5873 -31.08%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:2-4 11253 5861 -47.92%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:4-4 17824 5883 -66.99%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:8-4 32053 5871 -81.68%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:16-4 60512 5888 -90.27%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:1-4 79.5 70.8 -10.94%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:2-4 79.0 105 +32.91%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:4-4 79.6 109 +36.93%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:8-4 78.8 118 +49.75%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:16-4 80.2 132 +64.59%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:1-4 243 116 -52.26%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:2-4 243 171 -29.63%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:4-4 243 176 -27.57%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:8-4 241 184 -23.65%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:16-4 238 199 -16.39%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:1-4 2580 840 -67.44%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:2-4 2603 1175 -54.86%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:4-4 2572 1188 -53.81%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:8-4 2550 1191 -53.29%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:16-4 2585 1208 -53.27%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:1-4 39773 12181 -69.37%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:2-4 39946 17231 -56.86%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:4-4 39641 17179 -56.66%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:8-4 39835 17175 -56.88%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:16-4 40229 17215 -57.21%
== strings package ==
benchmark old ns/op new ns/op delta
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:1-4 5.94 4.97 -16.33%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:2-4 5.94 5.55 -6.57%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:4-4 7.45 7.21 -3.22%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:8-4 10.8 10.6 -1.85%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/1:16-4 17.4 17.2 -1.15%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:1-4 36.4 32.2 -11.54%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:2-4 49.6 34.6 -30.24%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:4-4 77.5 37.9 -51.10%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:8-4 138 45.5 -67.03%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/16:16-4 241 59.1 -75.48%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:1-4 509 378 -25.74%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:2-4 720 381 -47.08%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:4-4 1142 384 -66.37%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:8-4 1999 391 -80.44%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/256:16-4 3735 403 -89.21%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:1-4 7973 5824 -26.95%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:2-4 11432 5809 -49.19%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:4-4 18327 5819 -68.25%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:8-4 33059 5828 -82.37%
BenchmarkIndexAnyASCII/4096:16-4 59703 5817 -90.26%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:1-4 71.9 71.8 -0.14%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:2-4 73.3 103 +40.52%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:4-4 71.8 106 +47.63%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:8-4 71.2 113 +58.71%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/1:16-4 71.6 128 +78.77%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:1-4 152 116 -23.68%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:2-4 160 168 +5.00%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:4-4 172 170 -1.16%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:8-4 200 177 -11.50%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/16:16-4 254 193 -24.02%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:1-4 1438 864 -39.92%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:2-4 1551 1195 -22.95%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:4-4 1770 1200 -32.20%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:8-4 2195 1216 -44.60%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/256:16-4 3054 1224 -59.92%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:1-4 21726 12557 -42.20%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:2-4 23586 17508 -25.77%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:4-4 26898 17510 -34.90%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:8-4 33714 17595 -47.81%
BenchmarkTrimASCII/4096:16-4 47429 17700 -62.68%
The benchmarks added test the worst case. For IndexAny, that is when the
charset matches none of the input. For Trim, it is when the charset matches
all of the input.
Change-Id: I970874d101a96b33528fc99b165379abe58cf6ea
Reviewed-on: https://go-review.googlesource.com/31593
Run-TryBot: Joe Tsai <thebrokentoaster@gmail.com>
TryBot-Result: Gobot Gobot <gobot@golang.org>
Reviewed-by: Brad Fitzpatrick <bradfitz@golang.org>
Reviewed-by: Martin Möhrmann <martisch@uos.de>